Skip Navigation

Submit a Claim

For Active Policies on the Old Captive UMI Insurance Program:

Call: (888)-989-0943
Choose Option 2 to report a claim
Available 24 hours a day, 7 Days a week

For Policies with AmVenture Insurance Agency- United Methodist Church Insurance Program

Call: (866) 203-0777
Choose option 1 to file a new claim and option 2 to discuss an existing claim
Available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week

Reporting Tips

No matter how strong your safety and loss control program is, you will, unfortunately, encounter claims. Accidents do happen and prompt, complete reporting is the first step towards a successful outcome.

  • When reporting claims, report them immediately – don’t delay.
  • Collect as much information as possible regarding the loss such as contact name and phone number, name and address of the church or reporting location, parties involved, date and time, policy number, accident description and type of injury.
  • Submit all police reports, estimates, photos and any materials/receipts.
  • Do not speak with third parties about the claim and do not discuss “fault”.

Workers’ Compensation Carrier for both Old and New UMI Program Policies (Liberty Mutual)

Call: (844) 339-7453
Available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week